Pirates Trade All-Star Closer Bednar to Yankees Amid Front Office Turmoil

The Pittsburgh Pirates traded their two-time All-Star closer David Bednar to the New York Yankees for three prospects, including catcher/first baseman Rafael Flores, in a deal widely criticized as unfavorable for Pittsburgh. Bednar, who rebounded impressively in 2025 after a poor start to the season, posted strong numbers with a 1.70 ERA and was perfect in save opportunities before the trade, making him a highly valuable asset. Pirates general manager Ben Cherington justified the trade by stating the prospects acquired were their preferred package, despite none being ranked in MLB Pipeline's Top 100 and concerns about Flores's defensive skills and high strikeout rate. Fans and analysts condemned the Pirates' management for poor asset management, highlighting that other closers traded in the deadline received significantly better returns and questioning the team's commitment to winning. The situation was further soured by Bednar learning about the trade through social media rather than directly from the Pirates' organization, signaling a lack of respect and professionalism. Overall, the trade has intensified scrutiny of Pirates ownership and management amid longstanding concerns about the team's financial commitment and competitive future.