Arizona Homeowner Fined Repeatedly by HOA for Distributing Free Water

David Martin, a homeowner in Goodyear, Arizona, has been fined multiple times by his Canyon Trails Homeowners Association (HOA) for distributing free cold water bottles to neighbors during extreme heat, a gesture he began during the COVID-19 pandemic to foster community spirit. While the HOA and its management company, FirstService Residential, do not object to the act of giving out water itself, they cite community rules prohibiting advertising such distribution from a portable cooler visible from neighboring properties. Despite the fines, Martin continues his efforts and has launched a petition to remove three HOA board members, gaining significant community support with over 210 votes cast, 190 favoring their removal. Neighbors have expressed confusion and support for Martin, questioning the HOA's strict enforcement. The dispute has sparked a broader conversation among residents about the HOA's responsiveness and priorities. Martin remains firm in refusing to pay the fines and plans to keep providing free water to his community.