Carrie Underwood's Idol Judging Role Sparks Shakeup Calls

Carrie Underwood, the first American Idol winner to return as a judge, has brought both change and controversy to season 23. While her presence was initially met with excitement, recent episodes highlighted her reluctance to make tough decisions, including refusing to help fellow judges Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan save a contestant. Critics have noted that all judges, including Underwood, have offered limited constructive feedback this season, though some praise her for her candor and honesty. Mentor Miranda Lambert has publicly supported Underwood, emphasizing strong relationships among female artists on the show. Underwood’s experience as a former contestant has informed her judging style, but uncertainty remains about her return for another season. These developments have prompted calls for significant changes to the show's format and judging panel.