Judge Blocks Zeigler's Fifth Year NCAA Eligibility

A federal judge denied Tennessee basketball star Zakai Zeigler's request for a preliminary injunction to allow a fifth year of NCAA eligibility, after he challenged the NCAA's 'four-seasons rule.' Zeigler, a two-time SEC Defensive Player of the Year, argued the rule unlawfully restrains trade and limits his NIL earning potential by up to $4 million. Judge Katherine Crytzer found Zeigler did not show the rule had substantial anticompetitive effects and noted that alleged harms could be addressed with future damages. The decision is expected to deter similar lawsuits from other athletes seeking extended eligibility. Zeigler's legal team expressed disappointment but plans to continue their broader legal challenge against NCAA eligibility restrictions. The case has intensified debates over athlete compensation and NCAA policies amid the rise of NIL deals.