Steelers Sign Aaron Rodgers Amid Playoff Doubt, Coaching Uncertainty

The Pittsburgh Steelers' acquisition of Aaron Rodgers has sparked both high expectations and considerable skepticism ahead of the 2025 NFL season. While analysts and insiders acknowledge Rodgers' Hall of Fame pedigree, predictions for the team's success remain mixed, with some, like Pro Football Network's Jacob Infante and former GM Mike Tannenbaum, projecting the Steelers could miss the playoffs and that Rodgers may be 'irrelevant by Thanksgiving' due to age and competition in the AFC North. Rodgers himself has addressed concerns about his role, emphasizing his commitment to learning offensive coordinator Arthur Smith’s system rather than overriding coaches, and expressing optimism about his health and fit with the team. Contract details reveal significant incentives tied to deep playoff runs and even a Super Bowl win, but experts such as Mike Florio consider many of these incentives unrealistic, especially those dependent on Rodgers winning MVP or leading the team to a championship. Despite criticism that the signing reflects organizational 'desperation' to end a long playoff win drought, head coach Mike Tomlin and some observers remain hopeful that Rodgers can revitalize the franchise. The outcome of this gamble could have major implications for Tomlin’s future, as another failed playoff run might prompt leadership changes.