Analyst Ranks Patrick Mahomes 4th Among NFL Quarterbacks

Patrick Mahomes, widely regarded as one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history, has recently been ranked fourth behind Lamar Jackson, Josh Allen, and Joe Burrow in NFL analyst Chris Simms' latest quarterback rankings. Despite his slight dip in performance over the past two seasons and career lows in passing stats in 2024, Mahomes remains a dominant force, having led the Kansas City Chiefs to seven straight AFC Championship games and four Super Bowl appearances, winning three. Simms praises Mahomes as the ultimate winner and clutch player but distinguishes winning from individual quarterback performance, crediting Burrow, Allen, and Jackson with higher week-to-week play recently. Former NFL players and analysts like LeSean McCoy and Chase Daniel defend Mahomes' elite status, emphasizing his consistency, evolution, and playoff records, arguing that his contributions to the Chiefs' sustained success put him in a league of his own. Critics suggest that Mahomes sometimes conserves effort during the regular season, but many expect him to return to MVP form as the Chiefs aim for redemption in 2025. The debate over Mahomes' ranking reflects differing views on valuing winning versus individual statistical performance among the NFL's top quarterbacks.